Tennessee fans would never have believed this back in 2009 when Lane Kiffin spurned the Vols for Southern California. However, it’s true. UT has the better head coach.
Heading into the Vols’ matchup with LSU, it isn’t tough to choose Tennessee head coach Josh Heupel over LSU head coach Lane Kiffin. However, let’s start with the similarities between the two before we get to what truly separates Heupel from Kiffin.
First, both are offensive coaches that have been lauded for their ability to score points in bunches. Heupel did so when he first arrived at Tennessee in 2021 with a wide-open offensive scheme that was known for spreading the field (both vertically and horizontally) and scoring points almost at will. Kiffin has gone about lighting up the scoreboard in a different fashion.
Kiffin isn’t a pro-style offensive coach by any means. However, he’s been somewhat more traditional in his approach. Kiffin has relied on deft play-calling to score points while Heupel has hitched his offensive trailer to overall offense and play design. One would think that his past would work against Heupel at times when he hasn’t had success with that approach. However, that hasn’t been the case, which gets us back to why Heupel should be considered a better head coach than Kiffin.
Heupel has proven he is willing to win without scoring a ton of points. He’s done so this season with a stout defense and a ground-based, more conservative attack. Could Kiffin do that? If so, he hasn’t shown it.
Heupel has also shown the ability to make drastic changes to his coaching staff to ensure future success. He did that during the offseason when he replaced former defensive coordinator Tim Banks with Vols’ coach Jim Knowles. Meanwhile, Kiffin seems to be questioning his defensive coordinator at LSU during pointed public comments this week following the Tigers’ loss to Texas.
Heupel is also better by actual numbers. The former Oklahoma quarterback is 12-16 versus Top 25 teams in his head coaching career. Kiffin is just 15-28. That’s a big difference. Heupel is better when more is on the line, which will continue to be the case in this day and age of the College Football Playoff.
Games, playoffs or not, just mean more nowadays, especially top-tier matchups. Top 25 regular season matchups result in a better CFP resume. Then, when you actually make the CFP, games will be top-flight matchups. Would you rather have Heupel or Kiffin in those matchups? The numbers make it an obvious choice.
Of course, Heupel isn’t perfect. No coach is. Tennessee fans would like to see more discipline out of his program. The South Carolina game, in which three touchdowns were taken off the board due to penalties, was a prime example. The Vols are currently tied for eight in the SEC with 58.2 penalty yards per game. That needs to improve as it has been a consistent theme in Heupel’s time at Tennessee.
There was a time in which Tennessee’s uptempo offensive style of play could have been the main culprit in the penalty issue. However, not this season. The Vols struggle too often with misalignment and silly penalties that should be avoided. Nevertheless, Heupel has done enough to prove himself as the Vols (8-2, 5-2 in the SEC) take on LSU (6-4, 3-4 in the SEC) to prove he’s a better head coach than Kiffin despite his scintillating approach.
It’s worth noting that Kiffin, as the head coach at Ole Miss, actually beat Heupel when the Vols lost to the Rebels 31-26 in 2021. However, one game does not define a career.
The stories of Kiffin’s off-field antics and social media trolling are almost legendary. That makes him a better talking point than Heupel, especially with the national media. His lack of loyalty is also a factor in making Kiffin a “sexier” coach.
That’s okay. Tennessee fans won’t mind that Kiffin gets more than his fair share of hype, especially if the Vols beat LSU on Saturday.






